Contingent Workforce Management Explainer: Mastering the Fundamentals.

Top creators

Wowledge Expert Team
Principal level
127 Wows earned

Contingent Workforce Management is the strategic approach to managing non-permanent employees, including freelancers, consultants, and temporary workers. It enables businesses to flexibly scale staffing based on demand, access specialized skills, and optimize costs. Proper management ensures operational efficiency, legal compliance, and the seamless integration of contingent workers into organizational workflows.


The value of contingent workers and Contingent Workforce Management

Using a contingent workforce gives businesses the agility to respond to changing business needs, access specialized skills on demand, and manage costs more effectively. The process of addressing this type of workforce provides specific benefits to organizations, including:

  • Flexibility: Organizations often face fluctuations in their workload. A contingent workforce allows companies to scale their staff up or down based on business needs without the long-term commitment of hiring full-time employees.
  • Specialized Skills: Contingent workers are often specialists in their fields, allowing companies to bring in expert knowledge for specific projects without needing long-term investment.
  • Cost Savings: Employing a contingent workforce can lead to significant savings. Companies can avoid costs related to benefits, training, and other long-term employee commitments.
  • Risk Mitigation: By hiring workers for specific tasks or short durations, companies can reduce the risks associated with long-term employment, such as redundancy costs.

Contingent workforce management allows companies to tap into a vast pool of talent that might not be available or interested in full-time positions. If a contingent worker performs exceptionally, a company might offer them a permanent role. However, contingent workforce management also requires robust systems and processes to ensure that contingent workers are managed efficiently and compliantly. 

While hiring contingent workers offers many advantages, there are also notable disadvantages. Engaging a contingent workforce can lead to a lack of organizational cohesion, as temporary workers might need to fully assimilate into the company's culture or share its long-term vision. This transient nature of employment can also hinder team building and collaboration, potentially creating divisions between permanent and temporary staff. Continually onboarding contingent workers can increase training costs and administrative overhead. Furthermore, there's the potential risk of intellectual property and data security breaches, especially if proper vetting procedures aren't in place. Additionally, companies may face legal and compliance challenges if contingent workers are misclassified or if there needs to be clarity regarding their employment rights and benefits.


Understanding the types of contingent workers

The term "contingent worker" encompasses a wide range of non-traditional employment arrangements. The most common types of contingent workers or alternative workforce groups are:

  • Temporary Employees: Individuals hired for a specific time frame, often to fill in for permanent employees on leave or to handle increased workloads during peak seasons.
  • Contract Employees: Professionals hired for a specific project or defined period. They are often bound by a formal contract outlining their employment terms, duration, and deliverables.
  • Freelancers/Independent Contractors: Self-employed individuals who offer their services to organizations. They usually work on specific tasks or projects and are not considered employees of the company they're serving.
  • Consultants: Experts in a particular field who are hired to provide specialized advice, guidance, or solutions to a company. They may be self-employed or part of a consulting firm.
  • On-Call Workers: Individuals who work on an as-needed basis. They aren't on a regular schedule but are called upon when their services are required.
  • Agency Workers/Temp Agency Workers: Workers employed by a temp agency. Companies contract the agency for workers, and the agency handles their pay, benefits, and other HR functions.
  • Part-time Employees: Workers employed less than full-time, often working fewer hours than the standard workweek.
  • Seasonal Employees: Workers hired during peak seasons, like holiday retail workers or agricultural workers during harvest.
  • Interns: Individuals, often students or recent graduates, who work for a company to gain experience in a particular industry or field. Internships can be paid or unpaid.
  • Gig Workers: Individuals who take on short-term tasks or "gigs" usually facilitated by digital platforms, like drivers for ride-sharing services or deliverers for food delivery apps.
  • Casual Workers: Workers without regular or guaranteed hours, often working on an as-needed basis and typically in sectors like hospitality.

While these are some of the most common categories, the world of contingent work is diverse and continually evolving, especially with the rise of digital platforms and changing work habits. Each type of contingent workforce group comes with its own set of rules, regulations, and considerations for both the worker and the employer.


The key components of Contingent Workforce Management

Contingent workforce management is a multifaceted process involving several key stages to ensure non-permanent workers' effective and compliant engagement. When appropriately executed, it enables organizations to tap into a flexible talent pool, optimize costs, and meet dynamic business needs while ensuring compliance and fostering positive worker relationships. A well-defined process and supporting infrastructure is necessary for efficient and effective management of such a workforce.

Will be shown when leaving the editor

 

  1. Planning and Strategy: Determine the types of roles that are best suited for contingent staffing. Integrating contingent worker requirements (and costs) into enterprise workforce planning (WFP) strategies and processes is a vital part of planning.

  2. Sourcing and Procurement: Engage in procurement negotiations to finalize rates, contracts, and terms of engagement. Leveraging vendor management systems can support a robust and repeatable process of identifying skilled resources needed to staff projects and fill talent gaps.

  3. Onboarding: Provide necessary training, tailored enculturation, and resources to enable them to perform their tasks effectively and meet minimum behavioral standards and expectations.

  4. Compliance and Risk Management: Establish clear contracts to outline roles, and responsibilities, and protect intellectual property and confidentiality. Leverage vendor management systems to track contingent worker hours and length of service.

  5. Performance Management: Provide feedback and support to ensure quality and productivity, with careful oversight of how and what feedback is provided to avoid legal issues.

  6. Compensation and Benefits: Determine any additional benefits or perks for contingent staff, though typically less comprehensive than those for permanent employees.

  7. Relationship Management: Create an inclusive environment where contingent workers feel valued and integrated. Preserve performance histories to use in subsequent sourcing and engagement decisions.

  8. Offboarding: Ensure a smooth transition, whether it involves concluding the project, transitioning to a new worker, or potentially transitioning to full-time employment. Provide timely reminders for adequate alerts as to contract and extension end dates.

  9. Analytics and Reporting: Use insights (by skillset, department/location, etc.) to optimize future contingent workforce strategies and improve ROI.

  10. Technology and Systems: Use platforms, such as Vendor Management Systems (VMS), to manage task allocation, performance tracking, invoicing, payments, process and outcome measurement, etc.


How Contingent Workforce Management is used by companies at different levels of sophistication

Contingent workforce management varies based on a company's level of sophistication, maturity, size, and industry, among other factors. At a core level, companies manage contingent workers using simple (often localized and purely finance-based) tracking mechanisms and deploy practices that allow them to react appropriately to immediate hiring needs. At an advanced level, organizations deploy integrated technologies like Vendor Management Systems (VMS) to streamline processes, use data analytics for decision-making, and use proactive approaches for engaging, managing, and offboarding contingent staff. Meanwhile, at the emerging level, companies leverage AI and advanced analytics for predictive talent needs, integrate gig economy platforms, and focus on creating an inclusive culture that bridges the gap between permanent and contingent workers.


Understanding the roles typically involved in Contingent Workforce Management

Contingent workforce management requires synchronization across various roles to ensure efficiency and compliance. While in many organizations the role of the functional managers and procurement team are two essentials, more advanced organizations engage others to optimize the process and outcomes.

Hiring Managers: Know what skills are needed and how long the project will last, help create the job listing, and provide feedback on how the worker is doing.

Procurement Specialists: Get hiring requests, know the budget, and manage a list of preferred vendors. They strike deals with vendors, manage contracts, vendor relationships and payments, and monitor costs.

HR Specialists or Recruiters: Ideally, plan and know the need for contingent workers, plan worker volumes, and review job listings and candidate profiles. They are also the keepers of applicable company policies and make sure newcomers are appropriately onboarded and organize core training sessions. They should build contingent worker needs into employee experience enhancement efforts.

Legal and Compliance Officers: Review contract drafts and stay updated on labor laws. They ensure all contracts are drafted in line with business interests, flag potential risks, and help adapt company policies when needed. They coordinate efforts with both the procurement and finance teams.

Finance/Accounts Payable Professionals: Receive and process timesheets after managerial approvals, read contract terms, and receive bills. Ensures all contingent workers are paid on time and (with procurement) at the level prescribed in the contract, generates reports on what's being spent, and forecasts future expenses.

IT Managers: Understand what tech tools temporary workers need and deal with tech-related requests. Set up the necessary technology accesses and ensure company data security in line with policy and individual worker task requirements.

Analytics and Reporting Specialists: Collect all relevant data from the hiring and utilization processes and create reports showing what is working and what is not, helping the company make more intelligent choices in the future.

Project Managers: Manage project deadlines and project requirements. Gather and review feedback on the performance of contingent workers, providing feedback to workers or their employing companies as needed. They also report on how the project is progressing and plan contingent workforce needs for future projects.

Workforce Planning Managers: Assess the bigger picture of company needs and skill gaps, gather feedback from different teams and departments, and analyze data across types of workers. They develop projections and plans for hiring temporary workers in addition to regular employees.

These roles often collaborate and share information to ensure the seamless integration of contingent workers into the organization while maintaining operational efficiency, compliance, and achieving strategic goals.


Key trends in Contingent Workforce Management

Contingent workforce management has evolved in response to changes in the business landscape, technological advancements, and shifts in workforce preferences. Researchers and pundits have discussed the increasing availability and use of contingent workers as part of the "Future of Work" projections for several years, and data from governments around the globe have borne that trend out. Increasing numbers of workers are finding the flexibility, variety, and skill development they seek outside of traditional one-company relationships. 

  • Rise of the Gig Economy: The proliferation of platforms like Uber, Lyft, Upwork, Fiverr, Freelancer.com, Guru.com, and the sizeable temporary worker agencies have made it easier than ever for individuals to find gig work and for companies to source contingent labor. Professional workers seeking new work (or second jobs) are increasingly looking at short-term projects to build a portfolio of gigs to support themselves.
  • Embracing Technology: The adoption of Vendor Management Systems (VMS) and other technologies has streamlined the sourcing, management, and payment processes. AI and machine learning are being integrated to predict hiring needs and to match freelancers with appropriate projects. Such systems can be integrated into workforce planning (WFP) platforms for more robust analytic capabilities and workforce efficiency insights.
  • Strategic Integration: Organizations are increasingly integrating contingent workforce strategies into their broader talent and business strategies, recognizing the strategic value of a flexible workforce. Leveraging outside workers to fill short-term work or production surges, special projects, and skills gaps is core to this value proposition.
  • Focus on Compliance: As the contingent workforce grows, there's an increased emphasis on ensuring compliance with labor laws, benefits provisions, and other regulations to avoid legal pitfalls. Some of the largest technology employers ran afoul of such labor laws and regulations in the past, and serve as reminders to other organizations today.
  • Diversity and Inclusion: Companies are expanding their diversity and inclusion efforts to encompass contingent workers, ensuring equitable opportunities and treatment. This can be tied to developing and managing employee experience (EX) efforts for all employees.
  • Integrated Talent Management: A holistic approach that considers all permanent and contingent talent in strategic workforce planning. This is gradually becoming a key element of companies relying on a more significant percentage of contingent workers to fill out their labor needs. 
  • Remote Work and Global Talent Pools: The rise of remote work, means companies can tap into global talent pools more than ever before. This is already an enormous source of qualified talent, particularly with robust STEM, manufacturing, and customer service populations in lower-cost countries many time zones away from U.S. soil.
  • Skill Development and Training: As technological change accelerates, there's a trend towards offering training and development opportunities to contingent workers to keep their skills up to date.
  • Data-Driven Decision Making: Using HR and people analytics to gain insights into contingent workforce labor performance, costs, and other aspects to drive better decision-making. Much as enhancing the insights generated on the regular employee population, assessing the value or cost-benefit provided by contingent labor is increasingly valuable.
  • Well-being and Mental Health Focus: Recognizing the unique challenges faced by contingent workers and providing support, especially in terms of mental health and well-being.

These trends underscore the increasing importance and complexity of managing a contingent workforce. As the business environment continues to evolve, companies must remain adaptive and forward-thinking in their approach to contingent workforce management.


Considerations and lessons learned in Contingent Workforce Management

Clear Communication is Crucial: One of the most consistent lessons is the importance of open and clear communication. Ensuring contingent workers understand their roles, objectives, and how they fit into the larger project or company goal prevents misunderstandings and promotes efficiency.

  • Not All Roles are Suitable for Contingency: While there's a temptation to shift many roles to a contingent basis for cost-saving, it is critical to assess which roles truly benefit from such flexibility. Due to their strategic importance or long-term nature, some roles might be better suited as permanent positions. Conducting a critical workforce segmentation exercise can clarify the roles most suited to outsourcing, due to their lower strategic criticality and value to the organization’s primary value proposition.
  • Onboarding Matters, Even for Short-Term Roles: Skipping or skimping on onboarding can lead to misaligned expectations and a lack of enculturation. A thorough yet concise onboarding ensures contingent workers are productive and integrated quickly.
  • Regular Feedback Enhances Quality: Just because someone is a temporary or project-based worker doesn't mean they shouldn't receive feedback. Regular check-ins and constructive critiques ensure quality work and help workers feel valued.
  • Vendor Management Systems (VMS) are Game-Changers: Many companies learned the hard way that manually managing contingent workers can be a nightmare. Investing in a VMS can streamline processes, from hiring to project completion, and provide invaluable insights into the extent to which different departments, functions, and locations are over- or under-leveraging such workers.  Such data can uncover poor people management trends (e.g., high turnover, toxic environments, under-compensation, etc.)
  • Cost Savings Aren't Guaranteed: While there's potential for cost savings, effective management is necessary for costs to escalate. Over-reliance on contingent workers without a strategy can lead to increased training costs, turnover, and decreased productivity. The need for structured and rigorous analysis of the use of such resources cannot be overstated.
  • Cultural Fit Still Matters: Even if someone is only with the company for a short period, their fit with the company culture can significantly impact team dynamics and productivity.  Core to this is including some sort of cultural onboarding activity to raise awareness of cultural norms and expectations for such hires.  Working with contracting partners (e.g., temp agencies) and individual contingent worker hiring processes to include some sort of cultural match without violating relevant labor laws and regulations can support this.   
  • Legal and Compliance Issues Can't Be Ignored: With different employment rights and tax implications for contingent workers, it's essential to be knowledgeable about local labor laws to prevent costly legal issues. Including a legal review of all contracts and subsequent worker usage (nature of work, number of hours, length of engagement, etc.) is vital to a robust process. 
  • Contingent Doesn't Mean Disengaged: It's a myth that contingent workers are less engaged than full-time employees. They can be as engaged and committed as permanent staff if treated with respect, given clear objectives, and provided with the right tools. However, expectations should be set with managers and peers that due to the short(er) timeframe of such contracting, expectations for full acclimation and acceptance of company values and mores will not be possible.

As an additional note about expectations and processes, when contingent workers' contracts end, the transition can either be smooth or chaotic. A plan for knowledge transfer, offboarding, and potential re-engagement is vital for continuity.


Contingent Workforce Management FAQs

What is the difference between contingent workers and regular employees?

Contingent workers and regular employees differ in various aspects ranging from their employment status and benefits to the nature and duration of their roles. Differences can vary based on jurisdiction, industry, and specific company policies.

Nature of Employment: Contingent workers are typically hired for specific projects, tasks, or for a defined period. Their employment is contingent on business needs. Regular employees are hired on an ongoing basis and are expected to remain with the company long-term unless there's a termination, resignation, or retirement.

Job Security: Contingent workers do not have the same long-term job security as regular employees. Their tenure often ends once the project or contract is completed. Regular employees have greater job security, especially if they are full-time or have passed probationary periods.

Benefits and Compensation: Contingent workers often receive no paid or welfare benefits, and are thus employed without health insurance, retirement plans, or paid leave, unless otherwise specified in their contract. Regular employees typically receive a comprehensive benefits package, which might include health insurance, retirement contributions, paid time off, and other perks.

Tax Implications: Contingent workers are typically responsible for handling their own taxes, as they're classified as independent contractors, or handled by the agency or outsourced labor provider/broker. In the case of regular employees, the employer usually withholds taxes, and they receive a W-2 form (in the U.S.) at the end of the year.

Training and Development: Contingent workers may receive limited training focused solely on their specific task or project. Regular employees often have access to a broader range of training and professional development opportunities sponsored by the employer.

Flexibility: Contingent workers enjoy more flexibility in terms of working hours and locations, especially freelancers or consultants. Regular employees might have fixed working hours and locations, unless they're part of a flexible or remote work arrangement.

Relationship with the Employer: Contingent workers' relationship with the employer is typically transactional, based on the completion of specific tasks or projects. Regular employees have a more integrated relationship with the company, aligning with its culture, mission, and long-term goals.

Legal Protections: Contingent workers might not be covered by certain labor laws or protections that apply to regular employees. Regular employees are often protected by a wider range of labor laws, including minimum wage regulations, overtime pay, and more.


Will be shown when leaving the editor



Enabling practices and resources

Core Recruiting Strategy and Sourcing Practices to Effectively Identify and Attract the Right Talent.

Utilizing a “Workforce Access” approach enables organizations to cast a wider net and more intentionally take advantage of technologies and the full workforce ecosystem, including temporary workers, the gig economy, and even the crowd.

Leveraging Outsourcing for Cost-effective Services and Solutions.

A key element of planning HR strategies involves the decision to build internal capabilities vs. outsource those to a partner organization.

Incorporating Non-employees into Future Planning for More Robust Staffing Strategies.

Contingent workers, consultants, contractors, freelancers, and "gig" workers are terms used to describe individuals external to the organization who are paid to perform a wide range of work or tasking that assists the organization in meeting its production requirements.

Building "Future of Work" Considerations into Workforce Planning.

The "Future of Work" is a construct that is based on three major components - forthcoming changes in work method ("what" is done), the makeup of the worker population ("who does the work"), and the location of the workplace ("where the work is done").

The Recruitment Forecast Tool: Capture and Obtain Approval of Hiring Plans for Functions, Business Units, or the Full Organization.

The template allows the quantification of required hires for a specific deployment year to respond to strategies, staffing needs, turnover, and other factors.

Access full document

Become a member

Enjoy access to stage-based practices, step-by-step guides, and tools to build strategic HR programs.

      Get started for FREE