Table of Contents
- How big is the new hire turnover problem?
- The reasons behind high levels of new hire turnover
- The price that organizations pay for high new hire turnover
- Comprehensive solutions to manage and control new hire turnover
- 1. Assess and understand new hire turnover in detail
- 2. Strengthen attraction, recruitment, selection, and offer practices
- 3. Make candidate experience and recruiting teams part of the retention process
- 4. Optimize each recruiting effort or campaign
- 5. Formalize effective preboarding and onboarding
- 6. Equip and prepare managers
- 7. Help new hires integrate in human terms
- 8. Establish third-party check-ins
- Relevant Practices & Tools
As a CHRO, CPO, or HR VP, managing HR costs and the function’s contribution to business profitability is essential to effective stewardship. Employee turnover is a common metric, often tied to lost or reduced productivity from an operational perspective, but its costs are often underreported because it is difficult to assign a valid, accepted value. Partly because turnover is considered a fact of organizational life, and as long as it falls within a reasonable range of industry or local benchmarks, it is easy to dismiss. However, when considering new hire turnover, the associated expenses are higher and more painful, as they represent immediate, unfulfilled returns on HR and operational investments in HR and line management’s budgets, time, and effort. New-hire turnover between Day One and the first-year anniversary represents sunk costs that will never realize their full potential returns.
How big is the new hire turnover problem?
New hires are often presumed to be among the most excited and satisfied of workforce segments, as the new role can come with extra value that the previous role and organization did not, or could not, provide, such as higher pay, improved benefits, more responsibility, and/or greater perceived career options. At the same time, such a move carries uncertainty and risk, including the possibility that the employment sales pitch exceeds the actual experience, difficulty fitting into the culture, and challenges meeting the new manager’s or management team’s performance expectations within the projected timeframe. That is one of the primary reasons companies offer a pay increase: to compensate new hires for taking the risk and to incentivize the move.
However, industry research tells a different story: a surprisingly high percentage of new hires leave within the first 90 days, and more again within 3, 6, 9, and even 12 months of their hire date. For example, 22% of surveyed new hires reported leaving within the first 90 days. HRBench reports that the national median resignation rate within the first 120 days is 3.63%, with frontline-heavy roles two to three times higher; others find that 24% of workers quit within the first 90 days. The Work Institute found that over 33% of new hires quit within 12 months. That translates to the early, costly loss of over 20% of new hires annually. And it requires restarting the recruiting process and replacing new hires once or twice per year.
Also painful is that, at that level, new-hire turnover exceeds the average total U.S. voluntary turnover rate of 12.3%—for employees who just months earlier had been wooed, interviewed, and convinced to accept an offer of employment. It also approaches the total annual departure rates seen only in the highest-turnover industries, such as 25.4% in retail and wholesale and 19% in distribution and transportation. A simple analysis shows that new-hire turnover represents a significant portion of the total turnover rate experienced by the average U.S. business.
That raises the question of why so many newly hired workers across widely different roles, pay levels, and career fields make the same seemingly impulsive decision to quit after only a few months of work and acclimation.
The reasons behind high levels of new hire turnover
Once an awareness of the commonality and scale of the new hire retention issue sinks in, the next questions for HR and business leaders should be “why” it is occurring at such a rate. HR leaders can use abundant external research to benchmark internally collected data, most commonly from exit interviews or post-employment surveys. While issues related to the latter will be detailed later, organizations can use clear and consistently identified trends to understand and design better solutions to early-tenure retention issues. The most prevalent reasons for leaving (RFL) that contribute to new-hire turnover include:
Poorly communicated role requirements
Insufficiently realistic presentation of job duties and responsibilities, work challenges to be faced, physical and mental demands, pressures and stress levels experienced, degree of autonomy or independence of action, and the nature of existing relationships with customers or partners. Jobvite and other vendors found that 43% of early departures were due to the day-to-day role not matching expectations.
Cultural mismatch
New-hire turnover is surprisingly often due to employees discovering early in their tenure that the company's values, standards, acceptable behaviors, demands, and decisions conflict with their expectations and standards. The Jobvite research has borne this out with the finding that 47% of workers who resigned within the first 90 days cited a “poor company culture, 34% cited a specific bad incident, and 31% reported their “disapproval/distrust of company leadership”.
Insufficient development
Employee development and growth are widely documented as critical drivers of employee retention, regardless of tenure, and new hires are remarkably adept at quickly assessing the quality, coverage, availability, and accessibility of skills and capabilities resources and opportunities in their new employers. InsightGlobal reported that 60% of new hires who resigned early in their tenures cited disorganized or inadequate training as a primary driver of their decision to leave. Similarly, JobVite found that 28% of new hire turnover was due to limited career advancement opportunities and mobility.
Ineffective acclimation
Industry studies show that, on average, employees need six to eight months on the job to feel “settled” into the culture and work environment and competent in their roles. The worker onboarding process is essential to speeding up that comfort and fit, supported by InsightGlobal’s finding that 80% said they would continue their employment if they had a better onboarding process. As important as preparing new hires for the technical aspects of their roles is, so are the social enculturation that helps them fit in and feel part of a team, and the employee experience, which reveals how much friction they must manage in work and administrative processes.
Accepting a job under personal duress
People take jobs because they must replace basic earnings after a layoff, facility or office closure, or a poor event or experience that led them to quit without a replacement job lined up. These people apply for and accept a job as temporary financial or benefits coverage while continuing to search for a better career fit. Organizations that offer part-time or flexibly scheduled jobs (retail, warehousing and transportation, food service, hospitality and tourism) and small to medium businesses (SMBs) that need experienced, credentialed professionals but lack the resources and breadth of opportunities of their large competitors are particularly vulnerable.
The price that organizations pay for high new hire turnover
As new hire turnover occurs throughout a budget year, the costs add up fast. Consider how average benchmark levels add up to an expensive proposition if you lose 20% of your 200 new hires each year. That equates to 40 new hires lost per year, which costs the organization in terms of:
Higher recruitment activity and costs
Repeated efforts to promote, source, and fill the same positions lead to often unplanned expenses. Consider cost-per-hire (CPH) ratios that SHRM reports are, on average, $5,475 for each non-executive role and $35,879 for executive jobs. Gallup estimates replacement costs between 40% of annual wages or salaries for frontline workers and up to 200% for leadership and management roles.
Furthermore, the pressures placed on recruiters and hiring teams can be significant, as theoretically better-suited candidates (e.g., “silver medalists”, or selection finalists) continued on to other jobs, and/or lost interest in further or future consideration. This often means restarting the entire recruiting process within months of completing it.
Lost ROI of salary paid and productivity
Real, but often unreported, costs include the time and effort hiring managers, recruiters, and others spend on the hiring process. Consider what it takes to reasonably plan, search, screen, schedule, interview, compare, select, offer, onboard, and provide early-stage guidance for a single hire. Each time the process repeats, it takes valuable time from those involved, pulls them from other responsibilities, and saps energy that could be used for more valuable work.
Team productivity gaps
The loss in productivity and team performance after new or recently hired teammates resign can be significant. Workloads increase (again), production targets and schedules are impacted, and backlogs increase as the backfill hiring efforts are underway. At the same time, the time and effort those coworkers must spend indoctrinating, supporting, mentoring, and assisting the new hire is lost and must restart, further dragging down team output.
Comprehensive solutions to manage and control new hire turnover
Building an effective employee retention strategy should always include a significant focus on new hires to avoid the unnecessary (and controllable) costs and pain points examined above. A comprehensive solution starts well before the first day of employment, with job definition and candidate attraction, and continues through offer acceptance and onboarding, at minimum through the end of the first year. While many experts rightfully point to the first 30-90 days as a critical timeframe, leading practice targets the initial 9-12 months as the time to competency, and the time to feel settled socially and culturally is longer. With those in mind, leading practices associated with a comprehensive solution include:
1. Assess and understand new hire turnover in detail
Measuring turnover is essential; without insight into the reasons for early-tenure resignations, the organization cannot determine accurate, responsive solutions to control it. Assess turnover and the reasons for leaving (RFL) using multiple means, including exit interviews and anonymized post-employment surveys. The key is to understand where it is happening, who is leaving (including their demographic profiles), what jobs they held, which managers they worked for, and why they left. Collect the data, track trends, and monitor it continuously.
Provide context to reviewers and decision makers by leveraging local and industry benchmarking, as some sectors (e.g., healthcare, hospitality, retail, construction) typically run higher than others, such as professional and business services organizations. Detail reporting trends to separate voluntary resignations from involuntary terminations, new-hire turnover by role, job level, demographic characteristics, facility or location, etc. An especially powerful analysis for recruiters is reviewing new-hire turnover trends by source of hire, which can indicate which recruiting pools are more likely to produce longer-tenured candidates, such as employee referrals.
2. Strengthen attraction, recruitment, selection, and offer practices
New-hire turnover is caused not only by what employees experience after starting, but also by what they learn and understand as they enter the new situation. The organization's hiring communications and practices can control this to a large extent. Given what is known about early tenure resignations, recruiters and managers should place greater emphasis on the match between the candidate and the company culture, role, manager, and team, as well as the candidate's future value and potential for advancement.
Such a comprehensive approach starts with a realistic job preview built through role-specific reading materials, meetings with prospective peers and managers, and conversations with recruiters and honest assessments of the candidate’s aspirational matches. They should explain relevant, personalized career path options and associated development opportunities to every new hire, and press the candidate to consider whether the role, responsibilities, organization, and culture are truly the right fit for them.
Consider creating (non-discriminatory) self-assessments on the careers website about their fit with the company culture, work-life, and role responsibilities that interested candidates can take before submitting a formal application. Similarly, brief predictive turnover propensity tests that measure the likelihood of early departure can serve as “knock-out questions” that stop the application process if candidates fail to meet, or choose to opt out of, minimum qualifications or requirements.
3. Make candidate experience and recruiting teams part of the retention process
Candidate experience (CX) measures and identifies candidates' perceptions of the quality of interactions they have with an organization's recruitment and hiring processes, people, and systems. This creates a strong impression of how the company operates and can affect their motivation to stay or leave, especially when combined with their onboarding, early work, and administrative experiences. Regularly surveying candidates during processing and collecting follow-on data on the ease of accessing and processing their job applications and offers provides insights into how to improve these experiences.
Recruiters have a unique position in the screening and selection process, as they know candidates better than even the hiring managers, having developed personal relationships and detailed knowledge of their prior employment experiences, aspirations, preferences, and needs. Leverage them as ongoing relationship builders, and manage and incentivize them by measuring the quality of hire (QoH) of the candidates they managed, including new-hire turnover rates. They can guide and be responsible for introducing their hires to others with similar backgrounds, skills, and interests to help them acclimate and build networks that keep them engaged and retained.
4. Optimize each recruiting effort or campaign
While new hire turnover is inevitable, the organization can control it by staying attentive and prepared to manage it. Talent Acquisition teams should proactively stay in touch with “silver medalists” and other selection finalists to hasten the replacement process when turnover occurs. Candidate relationship management (CRM) technologies support this by helping teams attract, inform, update, and stay in touch with previously unsuccessful (but already screened as suitable) candidates, who can also refer similarly skilled and experienced coworkers, classmates, industry connections, and even bosses. This can substantially reduce the need to restart sourcing activities as jobs reopen.
5. Formalize effective preboarding and onboarding
Once an offer has been extended and accepted, engage a newly (to-be) hired individual immediately while their excitement and pride in the new role and organization are high. Keep in mind that these individuals are likely still in some stage of consideration and discussion with other organizations, so it is imperative that they are “locked in” before others can poach them. First and most important, establish this as a 6-12 month process, with programmed onboarding activities and actions in which they are guided to participate and tracked. Include required forms, selections, and submissions; task and workflow orientation; cultural assimilation; and network establishment and building.
Perhaps most crucial is moving beyond reliance on traditional portals, forms, and videos by making the experience human and personally relevant to each new hire. Make sure that the tools, workspace, facility, and systems credentials and access are ready on their first day. Arrange post-acceptance phone or video calls with their direct manager and colleagues, and provide pre-employment access (as allowed by law) to basic information and resources related to company policies, employee benefits, site or location maps, departmental mission, etc. Have task-related resources available immediately on Day One, such as role-related reading materials, learning portal links, and invitations to join relevant communities of practice, and employee special interest groups (social and professional).
6. Equip and prepare managers
Managerial effectiveness is a major challenge and barrier to success for organizations worldwide, with ever-increasing spans of control combined with poorly suited individuals in those roles. As a result, their ability to impact new-hire retention rates can be difficult, but it can be best supported through continuous training, coaching, automated prompts, checklists, and streamlined processes that remind them and ease their administrative burdens. Guide them to conduct frequent new-hire check-ins with tailored discussion prompts and scripts to gather feedback, answer common questions, and help employees adapt and assimilate more quickly.
Equally important is helping them set 30-60-90 day goals and action plans that engage workers with clear objectives, standards, expectations, and clear assessment criteria. Formalize development milestones and training plans that close skills and capability gaps identified in the selection process, and celebrate/recognize their achievement or completion. Automated, intelligent (e.g., AI-enabled) learning platforms that provide personalized recommendations for learning programs and pathways linked to employee skill levels, initial job requirements, and career advancement aspirations can reduce pressure on line managers to be career-track and lattice experts.
7. Help new hires integrate in human terms
New hire turnover is often tied to relationships with their manager, peers, cross-functional partners, and external stakeholders. As a result, their indoctrination and enculturation should reflect the nature and makeup of the relationships they will hold and experience. Support this by helping them interpret and navigate team dynamics and cultural norms, build early, constructive connections with peers, and develop a trusted, communicative bond with their manager(s). Crucially, help them find meaning in their work, role, and relationships, showing how those tie to the larger company purpose and strategic objectives, team goals, and customer or market value proposition.
Furthermore, when they join a team, members should participate in facilitated team-building exercises, as every new member changes the dynamics. Be prepared to address the existing team’s mission, operating model, principles, values, and preferences, with an acceptance (and manager oversight) that the new team member’s presence may cause disruption until they establish themselves in the role and workflow. This can often be smoothed by pairing the new hire with a peer, a more senior mentor, or a coach.
8. Establish third-party check-ins
Given the job and time demands of middle managers and senior leaders, an independent view of new-hire experiences and concerns can strengthen their efforts and support retention in the first year and beyond. Consider employee listening strategies, including periodic pulse surveys or early-stage stay interviews, at critical milestones such as 1 week, 30, 60, and 90 days, to assess engagement and satisfaction. Similarly, employee leaders, facilitators, or moderators of collaboration platforms, communities of practice, or employee resource groups (ERGs) should be trained and encouraged to identify issues or concerns that indicate a lack of connection and motivation to stay with the organization.
Relevant Practices & Tools
Core Candidate Screening and Selection Practices to Establish a Consistent Process for Hiring High-Performing Talent. >
A fundamental element of the human resources agenda and capability is evaluating an organization’s talent. This starts with assessing candidates as potential employees using standardized processes, methods, and criteria designed to increase the objectivity and accuracy of decision-making... more »
Developing Structured Approaches for Conducting Interviews that Ensure Mutually Enduring Fit. >
Moving to a face-to-face assessment process should be implemented once the job requirements and the ideal candidate capabilities are established... more »
Championing the Candidate Experience Throughout the Screening and Selection Process to Increase Efficiencies and Engage Applicants. >
Based on significant advances in consumer technology and electronics, many users of business applications and technology have come to recognize the opportunity to create a better experience for their users... more »
Assessing Health, Safety, and Wellness Culture to Reduce Injury and Illness Risks and Strengthen Overall Employee Well-being. >
Organizational practices can impact the team's health and wellness beyond team members' behaviors. The global standards for a healthy and safe workplace include identifying and addressing employee health hazards... more »
The Voice of the Employee (VOE) Worksheet: Capture Feedback to Identify Recurring Friction and Convert Insights into Targeted Improvements. >
The Voice of the Employee (VOE) Worksheet is used to capture employee feedback at the moment an experience occurs, rather than relying on delayed or aggregated surveys... more »
